There's a debate going on in professional golf that I find fascinating. And it has implications that go well beyond the PGA Tour.
The USGA and R&A have been working on plans to reduce how far the golf ball travels. There's even discussion about reducing driver head sizes to make the longest club in the bag less forgiving.
The objective is understandable. Today's longest hitters can overpower golf courses designed generations ago.
But I think we're overlooking a bigger question.
Are we making golf more difficult for millions of recreational golfers just to accommodate the extraordinary distances achieved by a few hundred professionals?
After digging into research from the USGA, R&A, Arccos Golf, and the Golf Course Superintendents Association of America, I found some numbers that might surprise you.
Longer Drives. Longer Courses. The Same Approach Shots.
In 2004, the average PGA Tour driving distance was approximately 287 yards. By 2025, it had climbed to nearly 303 yards.
That's an increase of about 16 yards.
On a 450-yard par 4, that should mean a shorter club into the green, more birdie opportunities, and potentially lower scores.
But something interesting happened along the way.
Golf courses got longer, too.
Consider Augusta National. In 2000, the Masters course measured 6,985 yards. VJ Singh won the 2000 Masters and his average driving distance in 2000 was 279.9 yards. By 2026, it had grown to 7,565 yards — an additional 580 yards. Rory won the 2026 Masters and his 2026 average driving distance was 334 yards. In context, Rory's driving distance was 19% longer than VJ's while August National's yardage increased 8%.
And Augusta isn't alone. Championship courses have been adding length for decades to keep pace with the modern professional game.
Here's where the numbers get interesting.
According to R&A research, the average approach-shot distance on PGA Tour par 4s was 147.9 yards in 2004.
In 2018, it was 146.5 yards.
Just 1.4 yards shorter over 14 years.
Despite significant increases in driving distance, professionals were approaching par-4 greens from almost exactly the same distance.
Much of that extra distance off the tee was being offset by longer golf courses.
Which raises a question: If professional golfers keep hitting it farther, and courses keep getting longer to compensate, where does it end?
And what happens to the rest of us?
Here's the Number That Really Caught My Attention
Arccos Golf recently analyzed nearly 10 million driver tee shots from recreational golfers during 2025.
In 2018, the average male amateur drove the ball 224.0 yards.
In 2025?
224.1 yards.
That's right. Despite all the advancements in driver technology, shafts, and golf balls, the average male golfer in the Arccos study gained a grand total of one-tenth of a yard.
About four inches.
Now, that doesn't mean technology hasn't helped golfers. Modern clubs are more forgiving, and proper fitting can make a difference.
But recreational golfers clearly aren't experiencing the same ongoing distance explosion as the professionals.
Meanwhile, according to the Golf Course Superintendents Association of America, the median length of an American 18-hole golf course increased by 56 yards between 2005 and 2021.
That might not sound like much, but consider what happens when a golfer who hasn't gained any distance is asked to play a longer hole.
If you average 224 yards off the tee, a 400-yard par 4 leaves a 176-yard approach.
Move that tee back 20 yards, and suddenly you're facing 196 yards.
For many recreational golfers, that's the difference between having a reasonable chance to reach the green and simply trying to get somewhere near it.
Now, the national course-length data doesn't tell us exactly how much individual men's tees have changed. But it raises an important question.
What happens when courses get longer, but the golfers playing them don't?
The Scoring Zone Tells Us Why This Matters
This is where my interest in the subject really comes into play.
Arccos analyzed more than 100 million shots from nearly two million recreational rounds, looking at how close golfers hit their approach shots.
For golfers with handicaps between 11 and 15:
-
From 60–80 yards, the average approach finished approximately 50 feet from the hole.
-
From 100–120 yards, the average approach finished nearly 62 feet away.
That's more than 11 additional feet from the hole when the starting distance increases.
And for golfers with handicaps above 20, the difference was even greater — approximately 21 feet.
And remember, these are wedge distances!
Imagine what happens when you're facing a 190-yard approach instead of 170 yards.
Longer approaches generally mean fewer greens hit, more difficult recovery shots, and greater pressure on the short game.
We don't have historical Arccos data proving that amateur approach distances have increased or scores have risen because courses have gotten longer.
But we do know that recreational driving distances have barely changed in recent years, courses have lengthened somewhat, and longer approach shots make scoring more difficult.
That's a combination worth thinking about.
The Hidden Cost of Longer Golf Courses
There's another part of this discussion that doesn't get enough attention.
Every time a course adds length, there can be financial and environmental consequences.
New tee boxes may require additional land, irrigation, turf maintenance, and construction expenses. Longer courses can mean more mowing, greater water requirements, and increased operating costs.
The USGA and R&A have specifically identified the continuing cycle of longer drives and longer courses as a sustainability concern.
To be fair, golf course superintendents have made tremendous progress in environmental stewardship, including substantial reductions in national water consumption.
But it still raises a question.
How much more efficient could golf become if we weren't continually trying to make courses longer?
And ultimately, who pays for those additional expenses?
For private clubs, it's the members. For public courses, it can mean higher green fees.
Should everyday golfers bear those costs to accommodate driving distances most of us will never achieve?
Maybe We're Solving the Wrong Problem
I understand why golfers want to hit the ball farther. Distance matters, and having a shorter approach shot is almost always an advantage.
But there's a difference between chasing more distance and actually improving your ability to score.
For most recreational golfers, I'd suggest two things.
First, play a set of tees that gives you a reasonable opportunity to reach greens in regulation. There's no rule that says you have to play the same tees you played 20 years ago.
Second, spend more time improving the shots that determine what goes on your scorecard.
The Arccos data makes it clear that even from inside 120 yards, there's tremendous room for improvement in how close recreational golfers hit their approach shots.
That's why I've spent so much of my career studying wedge performance, and why we focus on consistent ball speed, trajectory, spin, and distance control at Edison Golf.
Because you don't need a 300-yard drive to benefit from a wedge shot that flies the distance you intended.
Professional golf has a legitimate debate to resolve about equipment and distance.
But I hope the people making those decisions remember something important.
The average golfer isn't hitting the ball appreciably farther than he was eight years ago.
Maybe the goal shouldn't be to see how long we can make a golf course.
Maybe it should be to make golf more enjoyable, more affordable, and more rewarding for the people who actually play it.
I'd be interested in hearing what you think.
Until next time, keep working on your short game!
11 comments
Robb, you’ve hit on two things that drive me crazy about where the game is headed!
Your par 3 example is a perfect illustration of what I was getting at in the article. What was wrong with a 155-yard par 3 that gave golfers a reasonable chance at making birdie? Now you’ve turned it into a hole where a lot of golfers are just hoping to make par. And for what?
I also had to laugh at your story about the two young guys playing from the tips. We all tend to remember that one perfect drive and conveniently forget the other 13! But when that turns into a 5½-hour round, it’s not much fun for anyone.
I think we’d all enjoy the game more if we checked our egos at the first tee and played from distances that matched our abilities. More birdie opportunities, fewer lost balls, and maybe even a four-hour round!
Thanks for sharing, Robb. Great examples of exactly what we’re talking about!
Bill
Kurt, I think you’ve hit on something that could make a real difference for recreational golfers. And you’re absolutely right that most golfers don’t have an accurate understanding of how far they actually hit the ball. We tend to remember our best drives rather than our average ones!
I really like your suggestion of using simulators to help golfers understand their actual driving distances and then connecting those numbers to the USGA’s Tee It Forward recommendations. That would be a great service for clubs to offer their members.
I also think there’s a psychological hurdle to overcome. Too many golfers still associate moving up a tee box with getting older or losing distance, rather than simply choosing a course length that makes the game more enjoyable. We need to change that mindset.
And your point about pace of play is important. When golfers are playing from appropriate distances, they have more realistic opportunities to reach greens in regulation, which should translate into more enjoyable rounds and potentially faster play.
Thanks for a thoughtful suggestion, Kurt. I’d love to see more clubs take this approach!
Bill
It’s amazing that the driving distance of amateur golfers has not increased for several years with progressive advancements in technology for golf clubs, balls and lessons! I agree that amateur golfers need to play from tee box distances that optimize their game. Amateurs need to be educated on how to choose the appropriate tee box distance for play. Some golf clubs publish USGA Play It Forward guidelines for optimal total course distance to play based on golfers’ driving distance. The problem is that most amateurs don’t know accurately how far they hit a golf ball. Courses with simulators should have periodic events to measure golfers’ driving distance and build awareness of the Play It Forward guidelines. If implemented, the results would be happier golfers and faster play on the course.
Agree with you 100% on the fallacy of golf courses getting longer. Case in point, a club I play at quite often just lengthened a par 3 that was a nice 155 whites, 170 blue, and now it is 165 white, 185 blue. Turned a scoring hole into a penalty hole. However the golds have stayed at 135! On another point, the other huge problem in golf is people refusing to hit from the tees that match their ability. Played with 2 young guys, 25ish. been playing for 2 years. Have zero idea where their drives are going, but insist on playing from the tips, because once a round they will hit a 300yd drive to the middle! 5.5 hour round!!
Matt,
You make some excellent points, and I particularly agree that the game is already bifurcated in many respects. The equipment the pros play, and more importantly, the speeds at which they swing it, are a world apart from what most recreational golfers experience.
I think smaller driver heads and other equipment restrictions for elite competition are certainly worth exploring before we continue adding hundreds of yards to championship courses.
But your point about tee boxes is equally important. If we’re serious about making golf enjoyable for everyone, we need meaningful differences in playing distances between tees. Moving up a tee box shouldn’t just mean hitting from a different set of markers 10 or 20 yards away. It should give golfers a realistic opportunity to reach greens in regulation and enjoy the game.
And that applies to golfers of all ages and abilities, not just women or seniors.
Thanks for sharing your thoughts. I think you’ve hit on two important issues — how we regulate the professional game and how we make the recreational game more enjoyable.
Bill
Leave a comment